What Happens If You Add Too Much Butter To Chocolate Chip Cookies - Tasting Table (2024)

FAQs

What Happens If You Add Too Much Butter To Chocolate Chip Cookies - Tasting Table? ›

Classic signs of a cookie with too much butter include crispy-bordering-on-burnt edges, a greasy surface, an excessively brittle texture, and a predominantly buttery flavor that overpowers the other caramel and chocolate notes.

Too much butter makes cookies turn out just as you'd expect: very buttery. This batch of cookies was cakey in the middle, but also airy throughout, with crispy edges.

The higher the proportion of butter to other ingredients, the more tender your cookie will be (and consequently, the more it will spread as it bakes). I found that a ratio of 1 part flour to 1 part sugar to 0.8 parts butter was about right for a cookie that has moderate spread and doesn't end up cakey.

Butter gives flavor, tenderness and flaky layers to baked goods. It can also bring a bit of structure and rise. For instance, a chocolate chip cookie dough incorporates butter and sugar to incorporate air into the final result.

Increasing the amount of butter definitely makes the biscuit "taste" softer, more crumbly, and more flaky.

Too much butter will result in a very soft, sticky dough that's difficult to shape, and bakes up greasy and dense.

Adding butter or oil increases the fat content of the melted chocolate, making it smoother and easier to work with. Perfectly melted chocolate will be smooth, silky, and have a shiny finish, says KitchenSeer. If your chocolate is too thick or clumpy, you may be able to save it with some room temperature butter.

If you use too much butter, the cookies will end up flat and greasy. And if you use too little flour, the amount of butter and sugar will be proportionally too high, meaning the cookies will spread for the aforementioned reasons.

Also, underbaking them by a minute or 2 will help them retain a dense, chewy bite, explains Jenny McCoy, pastry baking arts chef-instructor at the Institute for Culinary Education in New York. Adding more moisture to your dough in the form of extra butter, egg yolks, or brown sugar will make your cookies even softer.

The ingredients you used could be the culprit – using different sugars, melted butter, baking powder or baking soda can alter a cookie's texture and taste.

Do cookies taste better with butter or oil? ›

The spongy texture and moist flavor that oil creates can be a boon to certain recipes. Not to mention oil is cheaper and easier to work with. Butter will always provide superior flavor and that melt-in-your-mouth texture. In many recipes, combining the two gives the best of both worlds.

Melted butter is best suited for drop doughs such as chocolate chip, peanut butter, and sugar cookies, as well as most cookie bars. You can usually adapt recipes that don't originally call for melted butter to use this technique if you're looking for an even fudgier texture.

For example, in a classic chocolate chip cookie, creaming together the butter and sugar incorporates air into the cookie dough. That air works with the baking soda or powder to puff or rise the cookie along with the steam created within the cookie thanks to the butter and egg's moisture.

Consuming too much butter can raise your cholesterol levels, specifically LDL cholesterol (often referred to as 'bad' cholesterol), according to Harvard TH Chan School of Public Health. High LDL cholesterol levels are linked to an increased risk of heart disease and other cardiovascular issues.

It is possible to overmix the butter and sugar. If you overmix, the butter will separate out of the mixture and it will be grainy and soupy. Be sure to stop once your butter becomes light and fluffy.

Keep in mind, this ratio of 1 part butter to 1 part flour pertains to weight, not volume. And weights aren't equivalent to cup and tablespoon measurements. So, for example, if you start with 5 tablespoons of butter (70.94 grams / 2.50 ounces) you would add half a cup of flour (72.5 grams / 2.56 ounces).

Classic signs of a cookie with too much butter include crispy-bordering-on-burnt edges, a greasy surface, an excessively brittle texture, and a predominantly buttery flavor that overpowers the other caramel and chocolate notes.

Butter doesn't affect just the flavour of your cookies, it has a major impact on their texture and structure, too.

Set your cookies on paper towel after baking

One of the easiest, most common fixes for combatting butter bleed is to allow your cookies to sit on paper towels while cooling and drying. Instead of coming through your royal icing on top, the excess butter will be absorbed right into the paper towels below.